Outer Banks vs Kiawah Island: Honest Comparison
Kiawah Island and the Outer Banks are both popular vacation destinations on the East Coast of the United States. Although both areas are located in coastal Carolina, there are some key differences.
Before planning your trip, keep reading to view a detailed comparison of the Outer Banks and Kiawah Island.
Location: Kiawah Island is located in South Carolina, approximately 25 miles southwest of Charleston. It is a barrier island that stretches for 10 miles along the Atlantic coast. On the other hand, the Outer Banks is a 200-mile-long string of narrow barrier islands located off the coast of North Carolina. It stretches from the Virginia border down to Ocracoke Island, located just south of Cape Hatteras.
Weather: Kiawah Island has a humid subtropical climate with hot, humid summers and mild winters. The average high temperature in the summer is around 90 degrees Fahrenheit, while the average low in the winter is around 50 degrees Fahrenheit. The island receives about 50 inches of rainfall per year.
Similarly, the Outer Banks also has a humid subtropical climate, with similar temperatures to Kiawah Island. However, the Outer Banks tend to be slightly cooler in the summer due to its location further north. The Outer Banks, or “OBX,” receives more rainfall, an average of around 60 inches per year.
Beaches: Both Kiawah Island and the Outer Banks are known for their award-winning beaches. Kiawah Island has 10 miles of pristine sandy beaches, with the Atlantic Ocean on one side and the Kiawah River on the other. The island has a variety of beach environments, including wide, open stretches of sand, secluded coves, and tidal marshes.
In comparison, the Outer Banks has a variety of beaches to choose from, ranging from wide, open stretches of sand to secluded, sheltered coves. The most well-known beach on the Outer Banks is the Cape Hatteras National Seashore, which stretches for 70 miles and is home to several popular surf breaks. There are far more public beach accesses, many of which with ample parking, along the OBX, making the area more accessible for beachgoers.
Activities: Kiawah Island is a fantastic choice for vacationers who enjoy outdoor activities, such as golf, tennis, and biking. The island has five championship golf courses, including the Ocean Course, which has hosted several major golf tournaments. There are also 20 clay and hard-surface tennis courts and more than 30 miles of bike trails. In addition to these activities, visitors to Kiawah Island can go fishing, birdwatching, and boating.
The Outer Banks also offers a variety of outdoor activities, including fishing, surfing, and kiteboarding. The island is home to several popular surf breaks, including Jennette's Pier and S-turns in Rodanthe. In addition to these activities, visitors to the Outer Banks can go hiking, birdwatching, and explore the island's many lighthouses and historical sites.
Accommodations: Kiawah Island has various accommodation options, including luxury resort hotels, vacation rentals, and vacation homes. The island is home to several resort hotels, including the Kiawah Island Golf Resort and the Sanctuary at Kiawah Island Golf Resort. There are also many vacation rentals and vacation homes on the island for rent.
The Outer Banks has even more accommodation options, including hotels, motels, bed and breakfasts, condos, and vacation rental homes. The island is home to several resort hotels, such as the Sanderling Resort and the Hilton Garden Inn in Kitty Hawk. Given that there are more options, accommodations along the Outer Banks tend to be more affordable than what’s available at Kiawah Island, which is a bit more exclusive.
Size: Kiawah Island is a relatively small island, with a total land area of around 10 square miles. It is a gated community with a population of around 2,800 permanent residents.
On the other hand, the Outer Banks is much larger, stretching for 200 miles along the coast of North Carolina. The island is home to many small towns, including Kitty Hawk, Nags Head, Buxton, Corolla, and Ocracoke, to name a few.
Nature: Kiawah Island has several protected natural areas, including the Kiawah Beachfront Management Area, which protects the island's dunes and beachfront habitat. The island is also home to several wildlife preserve areas, including the Kiawah Island Nature Preserve and the Kiawah Island Wildlife Sanctuary.
The Outer Banks is also home to several protected natural areas, including the Cape Hatteras National Seashore, which stretches for 70 miles along the island. The Outer Banks is known for its diverse plant and animal life, including several threatened and endangered species. Both areas are ideal for birdwatching.
History: Kiawah Island has a long history dating back to pre-Columbian times. The island was originally inhabited by the Kiawah Indians, who lived in small villages along the coast. Europeans later settled on the island in the late 17th century, and it has been a popular vacation destination for many years.
The Outer Banks also has a long history dating back to pre-Columbian times. The Algonquin Indians originally inhabited the island, and Europeans settled it in the 16th century. The Outer Banks is known for its role in the early history of the United States, including the first successful powered flight by the Wright brothers in 1903.
Crowds: Kiawah Island is a relatively exclusive, upscale vacation destination, and as such, it tends to be less crowded than the Outer Banks. The island is a gated community with a population of around 2,800 permanent residents, and it attracts a more affluent, high-end clientele.
In comparison, the Outer Banks is a more popular and crowded vacation destination, with a larger population and a more diverse range of accommodation options. Thanks in part to the Netflix series “Outer Banks,” the area has received a lot of added interest from residents of the midwest and northeast who had not previously heard of the OBX. Although, the hit series isn’t even filmed on the Outer Banks, which is another story entirely!
Nightlife: Kiawah Island is known for its peaceful, laid-back atmosphere, and as such, it does not have a vibrant nightlife scene. There are a few restaurants and bars on the island, but they tend to close early, and the island is generally quiet at night.
On the other hand, the Outer Banks has a more lively nightlife scene, with various restaurants, bars, and clubs to choose from. The island is home to several popular nightspots, including the Full Moon Cafe, Poor Richards, and the Outer Banks Brewing Station.
Shopping: Kiawah Island is a relatively small island with few shopping options that are almost all located within Freshfields Village. There are a few gift shops and boutiques on the island, but they are mostly geared toward tourists and do not offer a wide range of products.
In comparison, the Outer Banks has a more diverse shopping scene, with various small shops, boutiques, and malls. The island is home to several popular shopping destinations, including the Tanger Outlets in Nags Head.
Transportation: Kiawah Island is a gated community, which is not accessible without a pass. This exclusivity keeps traffic to a minimum, which is nice. The island has a network of bike trails, and golf carts are also popular for getting around. Visitors to the island can fly into the Charleston International Airport, about 45 minutes from the gated entrance.
The Outer Banks is more easily accessible by car, with several bridges and ferries connecting the island to the mainland. Visitors can drive their cars or rent a car on the island. The island also has a public bus system and a number of taxi and ride-share services.
Cost: Without question, Kiawah Island is a more expensive vacation destination compared to the Outer Banks. Accommodation costs on the island are higher, with luxury resort hotels, vacation rentals, and vacation homes commanding higher rates. The island is a gated community, and as such, it has a more upscale, exclusive atmosphere.
The Outer Banks is a more affordable vacation destination, with a wider range of accommodation options at lower prices. The island has a variety of hotels, motels, condos, and vacation rental homes to choose from, with something to fit every budget. Pro tip, visit during the fall for optimal experience and savings!
Overall, Kiawah Island and the Outer Banks offer visitors beautiful beaches, various outdoor activities, and a rich history. However, they differ in size, nature, and history, with Kiawah Island being a smaller, more exclusive island with a focus on luxury accommodations and the Outer Banks being a larger, more diverse island with a rich history and a variety of accommodation options.
No matter which vacation destination you choose, you are sure to win because each is a fantastic place to be for a week out of the year!
If you liked this post and are still considering your options, check out these other articles.